Venue Details

28 Star Starred
Arno Ristorante
West of Broadway 141 W. 38th St. New York City, NY 10018
Venue website Get directions
Goldstar Member
Staff ignored requests
Murdered by the Mob info Mar 14 2013 star this tip starred
Goldstar Member
Drinks were very pricy
Murdered by the Mob info Mar 14 2013 star this tip starred
View All 58 Tips

Reviews & Ratings

146 ratings
3.8 average rating
  • 48
  • 46
  • 32
  • 9
  • 11
4 events
4 reviews
0 stars
attended Dec 06 2008

Great show with a small crowd so you can really enjoy it. Only complaint is they put "Goldstar" members at a table where a big pillar blocks a lot of your view.

star this review starred report as inappropriate
61 events
44 reviews
7 stars
attended Sep 20 2008

Arno--Best chicken parm in America! Terrific service, too.
MBTM--Hardest working dinner-mystery troupe in America. Go!

star this review starred report as inappropriate
1 events
1 review
0 stars
attended Sep 20 2008

I went to this dinner because i had heard mixed reviews.. but quite honestly it was too long, they did alot of "interviewing with witnesses" which took up alot of time, and the food was ok - nothing great.

star this review starred report as inappropriate
View All 122 Reviews
Member Photos
20130427 211821
More Information


Quotes & Highlights

“It’s a hit! No pun intended.” —FOX TV
“…this interactive murder mystery is obviously a hit by any definition… funny and worth seeing” —ZAGAT Theater Guide
“It’s guaranteed to give you more laughs…this is actually funny” —The Daily News


The mob just made a hit but everyone is going to live to talk about it, and talking they are because, when the “boys” get together it’s murder! The Mob has hit off-Broadway to celebrate the induction of the new “Godfather.” 

Join the clan for a private audience with the Don, maybe he’ll make you an offer you can’t refuse. Mingle with mobsters and molls, meet the new “Boss of Bosses,” break bread and heads with wiseguys and Mafia princesses.  Sure you’ll  be rubbing elbows with goodfellas and ducking bullets over Broadway but it won’t stop the fun! Eat, drink, dance and be Merry, for tonight you could die … laughing!      

The two-and-a-half hour interactive comedy mystery features a three-course sit-down dinner and dancing. Aaay! You  even have the chance to solve the case and win some prizes. Seven prizes in every performance including “Academy Awards” for the best actor and actress chosen from the audience.

Dinner includes:

Bruschetta & Focaccia Bread Appetizers; Chicken Parmigana with Rigatoni a la Vodka; Italian Bread; Coffee or Tea; and Dessert. Cash Bar Available. (Pasta Primavera is a Vegetarian option but must be pre-ordered.)


Menu current at time of publication, but subject to change without notice._