I have to give major props to the performers for doing the best job they could with the material they were given. The performances were, for the most part, very good, which is why I am giving this production 1 star instead of no stars. But, the show itself was awful! I was skeptical about a musical version of 'Mask', but I did try to go into it with an optimistic attitude. The show opens up with the biker 'gang' singing a big, rousing rock musical opening tune. While it was a little awkward to see a bunch of bikers being musical, it wasn't so bad. The next song belonged to Rusty, and I actually liked it. The song was really good, and the actress playing Rusty gave a stellar performance. But, it was all downhill from there. In my opinion, the songs were awkward and they all sounded alike. I was actually embarrassed for the performers who were playing the high school kids--- their material was particularly awful (and they seemed to be embarrassed for themselves at times). Then you had the power ballads where the bikers are singing about their trek across the country --- it was more laughable than moving. Or a song for Rusty's breakdown, which made such a powerful moment extremely trivial because the song again was very awkward. That scene would have been very moving without any singing. It was like the composer and lyricist had a goal for how many songs they wanted to have in the show, and they threw songs in at unnecessary, unnatural places just to reach their goal.
The creators took way too many elements from the movie and tried to make them work on stage, and it just didn't work. (And the funny part is director Maltby's letter to the cast, which was included in the program, in which he says they will not be referring so closely to the movie. Please!) For example-- the mirror scene in the movie was poignant, because Rocky sees himself in a mirror that distorts his face so it looks normal. Well, the mirror scene is certainly in this musical, but it's awkward and clunky, with the ensemble running around (yes, running) and spinning the mirrors as they go. And, there's no moment where Rocky sees his new reflection, so there's no reason for the scene to take place in that setting. This scene could have very easily taken place in their home, and it would have actually been powerful, and we wouldn't have been distracted by the mirrors. The moral: you don't need to take every moment from the movie and put it on stage!
My seat was near the back of the orchestra section, and through the entire peformance, the creative team was speaking rather loudly (possibly into tape recorders) and taking notes. I realize it was a preview night, and they probably had important changes to make, but even on preview nights, we are paying customers and we don't want to have that distraction through the whole show. It's bad enough that you have to deal with cell phones ringing and audience members talking, we don't want to deal with the creative team making a ruckus as well. I didn't think I would have to deal with that at such a high-profile place as the Pasadena Playhouse.
So, would I recommend this musical? Yes--- as an educational experience. Go and see 'Mask' so you can see what not to do in a movie-to-stage musical adaptation.