I enjoyed the Civic Light Opera of South Bay Cities, as a theater, greatly as they clearly care about the productions they produce and treated this performance with the respect, care and grandeur it deserved. My only issues with the performance came from the casting choices, which I'm sure came, in part, from a lack of options, but none-the-less, it is why I am not giving it the full star rating. The sets were meticulous and beautiful, the set direction was on par with it's Broadway showing. The orchestra was wonderful and the setting was cozy while still feeling professional and James Blackman was a delightful afternoon welcome. The leads were veteran 'Siagon' re-casts from both Broadway and the world tour.
Jennifer Paz did another marvelous job with her role as Kim, however she was so good, her voice so clear, that she shaded the rest of the cast. Eric Kunze reprized his role as Chris but still seems to get hung up on how to move his body naturally when he sings. He tends to come off as a badly-animated CGI man arching in awkward ways as he fumbles his way around the stage. However his voice is so lovely and emotional that it can be over-looked. Misty Cotton returned to the role of Ellen and while her solo performance was wonderful and heartfelt, her introduction to the audience with the hauntingly sad, 'I Still Believe', seemed merely to show off Paz as a stronger, crisper voice. This is not to say Cotton is a poor singer, but rather that the song did not meld the two voices together as strongly as it should, which was a shame.
The Engineer, played by Kevin Bailey, is somewhat confusing. His performance was strong and he understands his role as grim, disturbing comic relief, however my companion spent the entire first act confused as Bailey is clearly not Vietnamese or French, but instead looks Irish, and dying his hair black didn't make that look fade, but possibly only heightened it. While ethnic look beyond generalities shouldn't necessarily matter in theater, that particular casting hindered my companions ability to fully understand who the character was and why he was there (they flat tell you in act 2). As I had already seen the show and knew the story, this had very little effect on me beyond the first minute or so, but I feel it important to mention.
Harrison White sang John's emotional 'Bui-Doi' off Key and flat and felt too effeminate for an Army captain in the Viet Nam war. While Kim's cousin, played by Bonifacio Deoso Jr., felt forced and halting as a singer, however his emotion was strong and came through in his acting.
The cast was a mix of races, the Asian cast mainly Filipino, but with theater, that fact can easily be over-looked and is understandable (my favorite Kim is still Lea Salonga).
The highlight was, of course, the set and grand direction, although Paz as Kim had me crying throughout so mega props her way as well. As a whole, the show was heartbreaking and well-run. I'm nit-picking the problems and feel it important to mention that I left this show a big step above pleased. In general I have felt LA theater to be severely lacking in both vision and talent, and so rate it on a scale all it's own. But with 'Siagon' I am comparing it to the scale of Broadway and London. That should tell you something.