Venue Details

1 Star Starred
Jimmy's No. 43
at 2nd Ave 43 East 7th Street New York City, NY 10003
Get directions
3 events
1 review
0 stars
Take photos if you can, it's a great event!
star this tip starred
3 events
1 review
0 stars
Comfy flat shoes because parts of the sidewalks and crossings can be uneven.
star this tip starred
View all 7 tips

Reviews & Ratings

"The Ryan Case 1873"
8 ratings
4.4 average rating
  • 5
  • 2
  • 0
  • 1
  • 0
24 events
10 reviews
6 stars
attended Apr 27 2013

I found this theatrical experience to be tiresome and contrived. However, I AM the world's biggest lazybones, and didn't enjoy schlepping around the nabe, searching for the crime suspects. (Although it was a perfect Spring day, and the East 7th...continued

star this review starred report as inappropriate
10 events
9 reviews
2 stars
attended Nov 10 2012

Over the moon fabulous. I wish they had a murder mystery show every week because this is a stellar,extraordinarily talented cast. This is the most exciting and fun way to spend an afternoon in New York. Can't be topped.

star this review starred report as inappropriate
10 events
6 reviews
2 stars
attended Oct 06 2012

"The world is full of obvious things which nobody by any chance ever observes."

Sherlock Holmes (The Hounds of the Baskervilles)

It is amazing the 'things' we overlook during the course of a day!

This event is fantastic and I highly...continued

star this review starred report as inappropriate
View All 7 Reviews
Member Photos
More Information

Quotes & Highlights

Visit the event website for a list of frequently asked questions about this production.
Check out what Goldstar members had to say about this event in the past.
A particularly fine example … of outdoor theater.  —The New York Times
The cast is excellent … peals of laughter … a fun evening! —
“It’s like CSI: New York_ in the 1870s.” —_TimeOut New York


The mystery begins and ends at Jimmy’s No. 43.

The show is appropriate for those ages 13 and older.

About half of this two-hour experience occurs outdoors. Please come dressed appropriately for the weather. Ponchos will be provided in case of rain.

Approximately 10 stairs must be climbed as part of the experience, which also includes a half of a mile of walking distance.

There is air conditioning in the Church of the Transfiguration.